NBC’s ‘Powerless’ could take a note from ‘Parks & Rec’

The wait for DC Comics’ first foray into the sitcom world has been longer than expected — but on Thursday (Feb. 2), “Powerless” finally premiered on NBC. Was the wait worth it? The jury’s still out — but we have a few notes for the Wayne Security team moving forward.

As it looks — right now, anyway — “Powerless” is aiming to fill the office-comedy hole in NBC’s current lineup. It’s a difficult balance, replacing the likes of “The Office” and “Parks and Recreation,” but the series — starring Vanessa Hudgens, Danny Pudi, Ron Funches and Alan Tudyk — creatively puts a group of ordinary folks together in a rather extraordinary world.

Charm City is plagued with a B-list of superheroes and villains, but so far the story’s hampered by the relationships of the team: There’s a lack of the friendship, or at least respect, that made those previous hits work.

RELATED: ‘Powerless’ is a world in which Batman is essentially LeBron James

Originally, the series sounded like it would be DC’s answer to Marvel’s “Damage Control.” But after the pilot screening at San Diego Comic-Con, the team quickly went back to work — with the goal of retooling the premiere episode from the ground up.

The story no longer follows a group of insurance agents protecting innocent bystanders against the inevitable destruction superheroes cause. Instead, soon after showrunner Ben Queen exited the series, the pilot was reshot, with a new scenario centering our team of heroes at Wayne Security — the establishment owned by Bruce Wayne — devising cutting-edge tools to assist in guarding civilians against supervillain attacks.

The synopsis shift happened quite fast and, with the new pilot, a noticeably different dynamic presented itself in the show’s characters — a palpable downgrade in tone. Thursday’s episode, aptly titled “Wayne of Lose,” delivers jokes aplenty — and the obligatory comic book references — but the characters have a long way to go.

We may be off-base in suggesting this, but you can only go so far with the dynamic of an out-of-touch boss — Van Wayne (Tudyk) feels like a Ron Swanson/Michael Scott hybrid — and a hopeful, optimistic lead — Emily (Vanessa Hudgens) is totally a DC Leslie Knope — before things feel outdated.

Taking inspiration from TV characters that have worked, especially ones that exist in NBC’s repertoire, is not a bad thing. But the “Powerless” pilot puts comic book expectations and uneven writing ahead of what really matters here: The characters themselves. Of course, a spotty pilot is more often than not the way things go, and there’s plenty of room to grow here — heck, “Parks and Recreation” is, for a lot of people, the perfect example: A first season that gives no indication of the heights the show would reach.

Now that “Powerless” is upon us, we have one simple request of the cast and crew: Spread the love. A superhero comedy with echoes of “The Office” and “Parks and Rec” is a formula for success — but that can’t be all it is.

RELATED: ‘Brooklyn Nine-Nine’: Captain Holt’s thoughts on Beyonce’s ‘Lemonade’ would ‘melt your face off’

To feel for a character — whether in TV or film — the audience needs someone to connect with. We caught a good look at Emily’s undying optimism on Thursday night, but that personality trait can only take us so far, amid so many so-far one-dimensional characters. Adding in the mutual respect that comes with the common thread of love between characters would simply endear the audience to Wayne Security’s employees — from quirky Teddy (Danny Pudi) to caustic Van Wayne (Alan Tudyk), and everyone in-between.

It may take some time for “Powerless” to find its groove: There was a time when we thought “Superstore” and “Brooklyn Nine-Nine” wouldn’t make it past their first seasons. But, those shows are great examples of a team finding their footing — remember back when Captain Holt (Andre Braugher) was unlikable, or when the “Superstore” team seemed to find each other more onerous than the duties they’re always complaining about? — and as we’ve seen, both programs quickly grew, and now consistently deliver the comedic goods. A sitcom is a lot more than its punchlines, and we’d love to see the “Powerless” team get there as soon as possible.

“Powerless” airs Thursdays at 8:30 p.m. ET/PT on NBC.

Source link