Style News Now

01/11/2013 at 03:00 PM ET

katharine mcphee 300x400 Tabatha’s Takeover: Katharine McPhee Should’ve Just Stayed Home
Jason LaVeris/FilmMagic

We all know Tabatha Coffey, Bravo’s sharp-tongued Aussie style pro, from her stint on Shear Genius and her latest hit, Tabatha Takes Over. And now, she’s bringing her talents online, joining us at PEOPLE StyleWatch once weekly to dish on some of the best – and worst – celebrity looks of the week. Keep in mind the opinions below belong solely to the stylist … though she’s probably saying what lots of you are thinking, anyway!

Today, she takes on Katharine McPhee, who selected a printed high-low dress for an NBC TCA panel in Pasadena, Calif.: 

Oh Kat McPhee, you’ve got to be kidding me! What is going on with this outfit?!

At first glance I thought your dress was a chintzy camo print and I immediately was like, “Oh cam-no!,” but now that I look more closely I’m thinking it could be leopard. Actually it doesn’t really matter because it just isn’t working for me. And neither is that length. I think this high-low mullet trend needs to take a break — a very, very long break. Speaking of length, Kat, it looks like you forgot your pants.

Now, what’s with the high tops? Are you going to the gym after your appearance? Were you actually wearing heels and one broke seconds before you stepped onto the red carpet? Let’s just pretend you did and call it a day.

I know, I know, I’m being a bit hard on you, but I’m not saying anything your best friend wouldn’t. Take my critique and run with it. And while you’re sprinting in those black high tops, stop into the nearest salon and get a blow out. Your hair is looking a bit lifeless. Oh, and one more thing … I actually like your lipstick.

–Tabatha Coffey

Tell us: Do you agree, or was Tabatha too harsh? Leave your thoughts in the comments below!

PHOTOS: CRITIQUE MORE STAR STYLES IN ‘LAST NIGHT’S LOOK’

google Tabatha’s Takeover: Katharine McPhee Should’ve Just Stayed Hometwitter Tabatha’s Takeover: Katharine McPhee Should’ve Just Stayed Homefacebook Tabatha’s Takeover: Katharine McPhee Should’ve Just Stayed Homestumbleupon Tabatha’s Takeover: Katharine McPhee Should’ve Just Stayed Hometumblr Tabatha’s Takeover: Katharine McPhee Should’ve Just Stayed Homereddit Tabatha’s Takeover: Katharine McPhee Should’ve Just Stayed Homebuffer Tabatha’s Takeover: Katharine McPhee Should’ve Just Stayed Homediggit Tabatha’s Takeover: Katharine McPhee Should’ve Just Stayed Homelinkedin Tabatha’s Takeover: Katharine McPhee Should’ve Just Stayed Homepinterest Tabatha’s Takeover: Katharine McPhee Should’ve Just Stayed Home

« »