Rise of Skywalker’s Rey retcon wasn’t even Star Wars’ largest

Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker spoilers comply with.

Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker generated a divide in Star Wars followers that we hadn’t seen since, effectively, The Last Jedi.

But one in every of its largest reveals was virtually universally disliked by each critics of the sequel trilogy and its supporters. That reveal was, after all, the revelation that Rey’s dad and mom weren’t precisely nobodies in any case.

In a retcon of The Last Jedi, Rey was confirmed to be a granddaughter of Emperor Palpatine, together with her father a failed clone from the Sith Eternal’s makes an attempt to clone Palpatine and convey him again to life.

As irritating because the reveal proved to be for followers, all The Rise of Skywalker was actually doing, nevertheless, was upholding a Star Wars custom: let’s do not forget that the most important twist of the collection was itself a retcon.

It’s doubtless a reality that the majority Star Wars followers will know, but it surely’s value repeating anyway: Darth Vader wasn’t at all times meant to be Luke Skywalker’s father.

– How George Lucas got here up with R2-D2’s title

The story was confirmed by Lucasfilm artistic artwork supervisor Phil Szostak final 12 months as he explored widespread Star Wars myths to show in the event that they have been true or not.

From the varied drafts of the primary film’s script, Luke’s father Annikin was both killed throughout the Battle of Condawn or by Darth Vader himself when Annikin and Obi-Wan Kenobi confronted Vader after they have been “young Jedi Knights”.

Whatever the reason for loss of life, it is clear that Luke’s father is lifeless and subsequently Obi-Wan wasn’t mendacity to Luke in A New Hope as a result of, at the moment, “Anakin Skywalker and Darth Vader were different people”.

The destiny of Luke’s father was retconned after the discharge of A New Hope when George Lucas was inspired by the merchandise licensees to place down on paper all of the official details of the Star Wars universe. He favored to do that by assuming the roles of C-3PO, Leia and Han Solo, and so forth and answering questions in character to an interviewer. (He’s made billions out of this, we’re not going to name him eccentric.)

According to ‘Leia’, Vader and one in every of his particular elite forces massacred the Jedi till only some have been left, together with Obi-Wan and Annikin.

But by the point Lucas got here to jot down the second draft of The Empire Strikes Back in April 1978, he had arrived on the main twist that all of us got here to know and love: Darth Vader was Luke Skywalker’s father.

As a lot as JJ Abrams may prefer to suppose the reveal that Rey was a Palpatine will ultimately be seen as an “inevitability”, it is nonetheless a retcon that seems like an even bigger one than Luke’s father because it got here after a giant revelation within the earlier film.

Perhaps if Abrams had labored throughout the entire trilogy, then we would have had the shock Palpatine reveal in The Last Jedi and it would not be seen as such a detrimental by followers.

That’s actually the principle distinction between the parental retcons within the respective trilogies. Lucas was capable of ship his and match it extra organically into what got here earlier than, whereas Abrams was seen to be straight undoing the work of Rian Johnson.

But whereas The Rise of Skywalker has its points, specializing in the truth that they have been making it up as they went alongside is to disregard that, actually, in doing so that they have been paying homage to the unique trilogy.

Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker is accessible on DVD, Blu-ray and 4K now, in addition to on Disney+, Sky Cinema Premiere and NOW TV.