Jake Gyllenhaal Taylor Swift Photographed Together On Coffee Run

Got’cha! We don’t see them together much, but one quick-thinking fan snapped a rare shot of Taylor Swift, 21, and May/December man-thang Jake Gyllenhaal out for coffee in Nashville over the Thanksgiving weekend.

Could it be? Has Jakey officially entered his first serious relationship since calling it quits with Reese Witherspoon more than a year ago? Tread lightly, Bro: She’ll write a song about you.

Love and caffeine seem to go hand-and-hand for these cute-as-a-button twosome. Excited fans also saw them step into trendy Gorilla Coffee in Brooklyn’s posh Park Slope neighborhood early Thursday. They ordered lattes made with maple syrup (if you’re into details like that).

“They were really sweet, really, really sweet,” a spywitness at the shop told PEOPLE, adding that the duo also tipped well. “They get treated like normal people around here,” added the source, noting that Jake, 29, deals with the occasional star-struck customer politely.