Because of Winn-Dixie

5 Comments

1. Graboidz

   November 6, 2010 at 1:19 am

   Review by Graboidz for Because of Winn-Dixie
   Rating:
   When I saw the ads for this movie, I was hoping I would be able to avoid having to take my kids to see it. The studio marketed this film like it was another “Beethoven” film with the dog doing all kinds of wacky stuff that only the 10 and under crowd would enjoy, “Racing Stripes” anyone?? So when I got home last night and my wife had rented the dvd of “Winn Dixie” I was less than thrilled. We popped it in, and within 10 minutes I knew this was not a standard kiddie flick. Sure it’s kid friendly, and the 10 and younger crowd will love the dog, and goofy deputy, but there is so much more to this film. To be honest the movie really isn’t about the dog, it’s more of a coming of age tale of the young girl. The characters all come to life and aren’t just there for window dressing or to do reaction shots for the dog. The acting is great, the story is wonderful (don’t be surprised to find yourself with a lump in your throat on a couple occasions). There is more “To Kill a Mockingbird” to “Winn Dixie” than there is “Beethoven”. A really wonderful film.

   Reply
2. Samanda b Jeude

   November 6, 2010 at 12:25 am

   Review by Samanda b Jeude for Because of Winn-Dixie
   Rating:
   One expects a movie pushed so hard as a ‘kid’s movie’ to be pretty dreadful … lots of sprinkles, treacle & gooey-goodness.

   Thank the gods, this *isn’t* 1 of them. The adult stars – Jeff Daniels, Eva Marie Saint, Cicely Tyson & [surprise!] Dave Matthews – are great, but the true sparkle is Anna Sophia Robb as the lonely daughter of an abandoned preacher in a tiny town w/the church in a convenience store. Enter Win-Dixie, a horse of a mutt [actually a purebred, but he *looks* quite mutty] shines as he helps the child tear down the fences beween people. Every time you expect the film to go into “aww!’ fulness, it swerves into a more considered and – dare i say it? – more adult look at the distance people put between each other … & how to shorten it into nothingnesss.

   Good in a wholesome – but *never* icky-poo sweet – way, it shows the delight 1 can find in a squalid trailer park, a convenience store-turned-Baptist chapel, & a dusty, small town in the middle of Nowhere FL [actually, LA]. Recommended.

   Reply
3. Carolyn Rampone

   November 5, 2010 at 11:57 pm

   Review by Carolyn Rampone for Because of Winn-Dixie
   Rating:
   The movie “Because of Winn Dixie” has been kept true to the book. I found it to be as charming, heartwarming and even a bit better in some instances in comparison to the printed version. I think it’s mainly Cicely Tyson’s ‘Gloria Dump’ that takes it up a notch. She was a perfect choice to play the blind women who teaches India Opal what it means to truly ‘see.’ I pictured Gloria very differently and was pleasantly surprised by the uncharacteristically scruffy Tyson. Jeff Daniels and Dave Matthews are men who have been hurt but still manage to take the risks needed to keep love flowing to them and from them. “Winn Dixie” is set in an old, rural town in Florida which made me yearn for a simpler time when it was safe for children to ride their bikes around town, explore, and just be kids. In that way, “Because of Winn Dixie” reminds me a lot of “Sandlot.”
   
   This movie is all about heart and it is a perfect family movie, for boys and girls, young and old alike and should be on everyone’s pre-order list. I really can’t recommend it any higher and I feel it’s a must have for everyone, even families without kids. It is THAT good.

   Reply
4. David E. Miller

   November 5, 2010 at 11:30 pm

   Review by David E. Miller for Because of Winn-Dixie
   Rating:
   I’m a 51-year-old guy, and I took my best friends’ little 9-year-old girl to see this film (recommended by my own mother!). Previously, we’d seen “Lemony Snickets: A Series of Unfortunate Events,” which I enjoyed immensely. Normally, we go see computer animated films. “Robots” is next!

   “Because of Winn-Dixie” is a true family film, and that is a genre I usually avoid like the plague. Maybe this film hit me at a time when my heartstrings were ripe for plucking, I don’t know. But I began shedding tears almost immediately after it began, and those tears kept pumping, even though I laughed here and there. I might add that my “niece” did not cry, but she liked the film a lot. (She’s never owned a dog, but this movie isn’t really about the dog, anyway.) I don’t know how this film would strike me on a second viewing. It has some obvious flaws, but it’s a wonderful film in so many ways that I have to give it 4 stars based on this one viewing. With respect to the young star, AnnaSophia Robb, I found her very adorable (but not cutesy), and, with all due respect to some other negative opinions expressed here, a wonderfully convincing actress. There are a lot of bad child actors out there (the all-time worst had to be the kid who played Anakin Skywalker in The Phantom Menace). But AnnaSophia is NOT one of them. I would recommend this film to any adult who has a big heart, and who hasn’t already been jaded by routine family fare.

   Reply
5. Jane Lane's Twin

   November 5, 2010 at 10:32 pm

   Review by Jane Lane’s Twin for Because of Winn-Dixie
   Rating:
   I was annoyed to find that 2/3 of the reviewers (or at least one) who gave this movie one star haven’t even seen it; they judged it purely on the ads they saw and automatically assumed that the book was much better. I loved the book dearly, and I actually read it when I was already 14!! I was so tired of all these stories about boys and their dogs, and how a boy needs a dog to have a good childhood; this was different, because I could associate with Opal so much better!

   Sure, there are a few minor differences–Opal is a blonde not a red-head, and that dog is anything but ugly. Big deal. It’s not as traumatic a change as having Harry Potter be a blonde and have no scar. People made too much an issue out of that, and also complained that AnnaSophia Robb could not act. This I must disagree with. That kid drew every emotion out of me that a filmmaker would want. She almost made me cry (on five occasions), and not just any kid actor can make tear up. She is a good actress in her own right, and I’m glad she’ll be in a few other films this year.

   The rest of the cast was great as well, even Dave Matthews. I loved seeing Eva Marie Saint in her role (it’s been a while for her to be on the big screen!) In fact the only annoying thing in this movie was the cop, thrown in for a few very cheap, very annoying laughs (like the wedgie joke). But he’s only in two scenes, thankfully, though the movie would be a lot better on the whole without him.

   Overall, this is one of those movies you MUST see before you judge it. If there’s one thing I can’t stand, it’s a cynic! “Because of Winn-Dixie” combines a sweet story with good acting, directing, effects, and all that jazz. It can be very entertaining for the entire family, teenagers included (if they’d give it a chance!). Really, you’re missing out if you decide to pass over this one.

   Reply